African Allen ambiguous American Amoris Laetitia annulment archbishop argued argument Arian Benedict XVI Bergoglio bishops Burke cardinals Catholic teaching Catholicism Catholicism’s century Christ Christian church church’s teaching conclave conservative conservative Catholics controversy council crisis critics critique cultural debate divorce doctrine document dubia ecumenical elected evangelization faith Father Francis’s German global God’s gospel Humanae Vitae idea interpretation interview issue Jansenists Jesuit Jesus Jesus’s John Paul II Jorge Bergoglio Joseph Ratzinger Kasper proposal kind Latin liberal Catholicism mass mercy modern moral Müller numbers orthodox papacy papal pastoral Paul and Benedict Paul’s Pius political pontiff Pope Francis pope’s post–Vatican priests Protestant question radical Ratzinger receive communion reform relatio religious remarriage rhetoric Rome rule sacraments Saint same-sex same-sex marriage Sandro Magister schism second marriage Second Vatican Council secular seemed sexual revolution Spadaro successor suggested synod theologians theological tion tive today’s tradition traditionalist Vatican II vision vote Walter Kasper wanted