the difference is worth an effort,—and if it (others, would have gone to the guillotine infail, it is but death at last! But that effort stead of himself and his brother and Saintthe adroit speech-maker cannot make: the Just. But even then, had he by the aid of quality that can make such efforts succeed such a military commandant as Bonaparte is not his. If he had but a man instead of survived the bloody turmoil of contending a drunken ruffian to work his guns, they factions and exercised his power in a calmmight still, if well served, blow the opposi- er atmosphere, how long would he have tion into the air. But the hour is past, done so ? How long would it have been -the tide has turned for ever for Maximil- | before he must have given place to a logic ien Robespierre and his fortunes !

more irresistible than his own,-that of the It has been said, and we think not with successful soldier, whom the same wars out grounds, that Robespierre had serious that helped him to retain his power had thoughts of closing the Reign of Terror rendered all-powerful? with the execution of that last batch of his In an age of cant any man's moral charcolleagues which included the most blood-acter is a difficult topic;—that of a man thirsty ruffians produced in the whole course like Robespierre is also perhaps a dangerof the Revolution. The opposition which ous one. Yet why should we not do what (as he states in his last speech) he made to lies in our power to strip off false colorings his colleagues' proposal of a decree of ac- and get at truth? Lord Brougham says cusation against the sixty-two imprisoned justly that Robespierre is a name at which members of the Convention, favors the sup- men still shudder. It is indeed a name enposition that he meant to release those dep-circled with a haze of blood, which frightuties, to strengthen himself in carrying out ens the multitude and confuses the vision some plan in which he was likely to be op- even of some who would not reckon them. posed by his present colleagues in the selves of the multitude. Committees. And Napoleon, who believed But it is not necessary in explaining that Robespierre was an honest fanatic, told Robespierre's character to regard him as a Mr. O'Meara, that he had himself seen monster,—that is, as a human being out of letters from Robespierre to his brother, the course of nature. The French people then representing the people with the army were driven, by revolutionary excitement of Nice, which proved his determination to and wild fears of counter-revolution, into a bring the Reign of Terror to an end. That state of phrenzy. When people are in such he was cut off in the midst of some such a state, it is useless to talk of acting with plan, which he wanted nerve to execute, moderation. The first intemperate act proLord Brougham thinks highly probable; duces a state of mind and body resembling and certainly his hostile designs against that of men who have stormed a town and Billaud and Collot are not inconsistent are proceeding to sack it. In that boiling with such a plan, since it would proba- state of the blood things at other times the bly have been quite impracticable with most sacred lose their sanctity, human life such sanguinary colleagues as they. It becomes a commodity of small value, blood appears, however, very doubtful whether is poured forth like water. In this state any amount of nerve in Robespierre him- the leaders, having abundantly used against self, with such a commandant-general of those whom they viewed as the mortal enethe guard of Paris as Henriot under him, mies of their cause, the last punishment would have sufficed. If he could have plac- which man can inflict on man-deathed Napoleon Bonaparte in the place of easily fell into the habit of viewing milder Henriot, though but for twenty-four hours, punishments as inefficient. An ancient he would assuredly have been dictator of deadly enemy is not hated with a more faFrance for some time longer. Billaud and tal hatred than an ancient friend turned riCollot and Barère and Tallien, Vadier, val. Robespierre, it is said, was by nature, Bourdon (de l'Oise), Léonard Bourdon and above other men, a man of blood. He was,

let it be granted, proud, reserved, revenge* Whose authority, Lord Brougham says, is ful, ambitious, overvaluing himself, underwholly unimpeachable. His Lordship adds in a valuing others, using them but as tools to note, “ I happen to know facts unknown to Mr be cast aside when done with. O'Meara when he was writing. Napoleon's allu English politicians are there, without dissions to those same facts, e. g. Secret Negotiations tinction of party, who are all this, and more with Spain in 1806 ; and thus those allusions were to him unintelligible." —Sketches, vol. iii. p. 68, and worse than all this, and yet bear not note.

an execrated name like his, nor leave be

How many

hind them like him a scorched and black- f in his speech in the Jacobins, on the 28th of ened memory! But he had “cast away all April, 1792), "Je ne suis ni le courtisan, regard to principle” and was “callous to all ni le modérateur, ni le tribun, ni le défenhuman feelings." And yet the man had seur du peuple !-je suis peuple moi-même." faith—“ believed every word he uttered;" But in April, 1794, he night have inserted and for principle, all the wealth and luxury the definite article and said, with the subof the world could not shake his honesty ; stitution of “ peuple” for “ état" in the exand for feeling, his poor landlord, the car- clamation of Louis XIV.,—"le peuple ! penter “in the Rue St. Honoré, loved him, c'est moi !" A whole people is a sovereign, -his brother died for him.” Ay, shower whose will cannot easily be manifested on reproaches on the man of blood, but re- all occasions; it must have some accessible member that he was not a quack, that be exponent or index. The Freuch were conwas not a liar, that he was not a renegade! tent to acknowledge for a time such an in

But, independently either of intellectual dex in Robespierre. In him was embodied or moral considerations, Robespierre, that the spirit of the French democracy; conseis to say the mere existence of the individ- quently his word was a law from which ual so called, was not only a great, but a there was no appeal :-his power was a dessingular fact. It stands alone, with nothing potism from which there was no escape ; like to it. In the course of the world's dark, swift, inevitable, unrelenting, it knew history three men have stood out pre-emi- neither forgiveness, nor pity, nor remorse. nent among mankind for the vast power Even in his last speeches there is not a which they acquired by their abilities, – trace of any thing that can be construed into Cæsar, Cromwell, and Bonaparte. But the slightest expression of sorrow, of regret those abilities were exerted from a certain for the sad fate of so many men who had vantage-ground: their minds and wills did once been his friends, who had once even not come into direct and immediate colli- loved him, whom he had murdered in cold sion with the minds and wills of other men. blood and in the prime of manhood. He There was an intermediate link, a connect continues to speak of them to the last as a ing medium, which took from the operation fanatic of the darkest ages would speak of the simple character of the action of mind his victims, describing them as God's eneupon mind, mixing up instead thereof some mies, justly punished for their black and what of the action of matter upon mind, and horrible sins. When a human selfishness, rendering thereby their logic irresistible. fierce and ravenous as that of the most feroBut in the ancient and modern world there cious wild beast, regards its own gratificahas appeared but one man, who, without tion as a duty and a virtue,* we have the their vantage-ground, attained for a season degree of fanaticism, whether religious or a power comparable to theirs. Robes- political, which has raised so many scaffolds pierre's power in the Convention, though and lighted so many fires. And this must not quite equal to Cromwell's in his parlia- be viewed as the master key to Robesment, and to Napoleon's in his, was as great pierre's character. Napoleon was a fanatic as Cæsar's in the senate. He was obliged of another kind; the selfishness in him was to go by a somewhat more circuitous way as vehement and fierce, but the sense of to his end than a despot of the miltary kind, duty and virtue in its gratification either but he did not the less surely reach that not so strong, or the field of its operation end; for it was death to obstruct his path. much wider. The world has had several To contradict him in any thing became at specimens of military, and but this one of last as dangerous as it was to contradict oratorical dictatorship; and certainly if this Henry VIII. in an argument on the re- be a fair specimen, we desire to have no spective merits of Catholicisto and Protest- more. It would be a thousand times better to antism. There is no other instance, we belive under the despotism of Cæsar, CromJieve, of such power having been attained well, or Napoleon, than under that of Maxby mere political and rhetorical ability. Similien Robespierre. Demosthenes was but the minister of the Athenian people,–Cicero that of the Ro * In his last speech this man of blood exclaims, man oligarchy: but Robespierre was not “ Otez moi ma conscience, je suis le plus mal

heureux de tous les hommes. the man, but the master. He was not so much the servant of the French people as (strange though the phrase may sound) the French people itself. Robespierre once said

EXPEDITION OF DR. LEPSIUS IN EGYPT. and hung with bonbons; passing away the

ime by exchanging visits with several Turkish From the Literary Gazette.

authorities, who, like themselves, were de.

tained at this entrance to the wilderness. At Cairo, May 29, 1841.

last,their patience exhausted, they resolved on My dear Sir,-In my last account of the energetic measures, and with difficulty proPrussian mission, I mentioned to you the pro-cured eight canels, two diseased, two fatigued. bability of being some time without news from and one lame. However, with this inadequate them as they advanced towards the southern supply, Dr. Lepsius and his friend Mr. Abeextremity of their nuission, beyond the limits ken, a servant, and an interpreter, launched of civilization. That being the case, you will into the desert on the 8th of January, and arnot be surprised at this long interval, which, rived safely at Abu Hamed on the morning of though long as it is, I can fill up from the the 17th. On the road they met a caravan letters of my excellent correspondent with in- that gave them the satisfactory intelligence teresting details.

that their karvas bad passed by another tract At Korosko (the northern entrance to the with sixty camels. At Abu Hamed, refrı shed desert that occupies the space formed by a and provided with an additional camel, they great curve in the valley of the Nile), where I continued their route, which now lay on the left the party detained for want of camels to banks of the river, sometimes beautitully corconvey them and their baggage to Berber, they ered with splendid acacias, groves of doom procured a small boat, and on the 8th of De- palms, small villages, and ihe patriarcha! cember set sail, leaving the camp under the dwellings of the sheiks, and much that was protection of the Prussian eagle and the in- interesting and new to them, till, on the mornvincible Franke. They reached Wady Flalfa ing of the 21st of January, they arrived at Elon the 13th, and were returned to their purga- mekhegrif

, the capital of Dar Berber. The tory at Korosko on the 22d, having examined next day they proceeded to Damer, where most of the antiquities very minutely, leaving they found themselves in the midst of a Turkthe drawing for a future visit. Of Abu Simbal ish camp and warlike preparations for the esmy correspondent writes:--"Splendid as it is, pedition against Raka; here they remained the colossi, bassi relievi, and hieroglyphics, are four days, and started on the 2sih in a fine far inferior in point of style to those of the large boat, which the aid-de-camp of Ahmed time of his father Menephthah, and still more Pasha Nimikly (the new governor of Sennar) to those of the period of Amunoph III. The had offered them, not displeased to exchange style of the sculptures of the time of Rhamses the ship of the desert for that of the river; and II. I find generally bad, and those of Rhamses on the same evening, the 28th, moored near III. (Miamun, the Rhamses IV. of the Freoch) the pyramids of Wady Assoor, at the village abominable. But Amunoph III. and Meneph- of Beggarowish. Arrived in the ancient and thah are like Phidias anu Praxiteles, the former fabulous Meroe, near its capital and tombs of excelling all Egyptian sculptures in sublimity its kings, they could not resist the temptation and grandeur, the latter in grace and sweet- of visiting the pyramids the same evening, by ness; indeed there is nothing in Egypt that the feeble light afforded by the moon in its surpasses in sublime grandeur the Memnon first quarter, and feeling the hieroglyphics in colossi in the plain of Thebes, or the chaste the porticos and propyla. The result of the purity of the hieroglyphics of this period. next morning's investigation fully confirmed How sudden here, too, the decay of art! From their previous examination; nothing very anAmunoph III. 10 Rhamses I., a few genera- cient was found; a great many cartouches. tions; and if we cumpare the sixth dynasty to high-sounding titles, and old Egyptian names, the fourth, must we not make the same remark? adopted in imitation of better times, but every Is this, then, the sad but unavoidable law of thing, bassi relievi and hieroglyphics, in the humanity? A curious style is that of the Oser- very worst style of the latter ages, nothing tasens, an overgrown civilization. You recol- ceriainly beyond the Ptolemaic period, and lect the tablets above Abu Simbal, where an most much more modern: "as you know very Osertasen is worshipped, as in the temple of well, it is impossible to mistake this latter barAmada, and also, I believe, in the temple of barity for the presumed rudeness of early Semneh, and the style of the soi-disant Skeyą times; every thing in imitation of Egyp(whose comb is near Amunoph's). We found Egyptian divinities, letters, language, as it also during this journey, some reasons for the seems, but it will require further investigation identity of Rhamses with or without hiero- to decide whether at least there is not a pecuglyph, and many other curious things.” liar dialect. You will be amused to hear that,

On the return of the party to the encamp- for the first time, we found a camel representment at Korosko, they were much discomfited ed." The doctor and his companion found a at not finding news from their Turkish karvas, great many names of kings, of whom most whom they had despatched to Berber for probably little more will be known, and many camels. At this miserable place they were cartouches purposely mutilated. On the 29th. obliged to pass their Christmas and New- the architect, Heer Erbkam, joined them with year's day, at which festivals they did not omit the rest of the members of the mission. On ihe national pastimes, nor the tree illuminated the 30th they visited Shendy; and on the 31st,

[ocr errors]

Beni Naga, where exist the ruins of a temple. De JOINVILLE.-A perusal of the Prince de with Typhonic columns, and the remains of Joinville's very clever note on the state of the some other edifices with bassi relievi and in- French navy, confirms our opinion of its origin. scriptions much mutilated, “but evidently also The young admiral burns for distinction ; the of a very late period.” From thence they peace of the seas denies it him; and he rushes proceeded, on the 1st of February, eight or

into print. And very well he acquits himself. nine hours into the desert, to see the ruins of His note is a strictly professional effusion : he Naga or Gebel Arden, copied the inscriptions rine, (which he acutely perceives to be a modi

sees the French navy, especially the steam maand cartouches unknown. "There is clearly fication of shipping suited to the unnautical French in this ruin an influence of Roman architec- nation,) in a state of deplorable inefficiency; he ture.” On the 2d they visited the ruins at desires to procure an efficient steam marine Mesaurat or Wady Sutra (not Owataib, as would he not signalize himself in its management Hoskins calls them, the latter name belonging and use ?-and accordingly he sets forth how to the valley that extends froin Beni Naga, at weak is that arm of France, and how strong and the Nile, to Naga in the desert); a curious as- effective it might be made. This is done in lansemblage of walls, columns, halls, courts, stair-guage which is plain, terse, and pithy; there is cases, corridors, temples, &c., without hiero- no enfeebling rhetoric-every sentence tells home glyphics, and only a few bussi' relievi of hum--the reader is convinced as he reads. Glance ble style.

“ To me they appear to have beyond the professional view, indeed, and you formed a country residence or hunting place clearsighted and clever a man, coming, too, from

are struck with the crude statesmanship of so of some king of Meroe. I dare affirm, that on the whole island or peninsula of Meroe, there so prudent a family; for nothing can be more inis not one vestige of remote antiquity; and for oportune and indiscreet than the talk about war

ring with England, which he assumes among his my part have no doubt that Ethiopia derived

data. And there are other warlike allusions iis religion, literature, and civilization, from which could not but act like a match thrown Egypt, and that at a comparatively late time. among gunpowder, when promulgated in Paris. We are anxious now to see the works of That collateral tendency of his pamphlet may Terhaka at Gebel Barkal, and to try if we have recommended it to others more cunning and can inake out a link between him and the more malicious, and have procured him the adlater Ethiopians of Meroe. Did he come, vice to publish it. Once determined, it is not too, from Meroe ? He has lest no monument surprising that he should have been obstinate in there."

refusing to give up his darling work, so likely to On the 5th of February, the partyarrived at do him credit, and at least to make a noise. The Kartoum, the town at the junction of the White papers bad last week a story how he threatened, and Blue Rivers. At this new metropolis of

some time back, to resign, because Admiral DuUpper Nubia they stayed till the 17th, making father's anger-how he succumbed to the tearful

petit-Thouars was given up-how he resisted his a few excursions, particularly on the White entreaties of his venerable mother: this week stream, the banks of which are flat, but magni- they have the very counterpart of the story, but ficently wooded; and on the 17th they again now it is about the pamphlet; only they say that separated, the architect and some of the mem- the king was so far party to a compromise, that he bers to prosecute the work at Naga, while the asked, and even executed with his own hand, the doctor and his friend made a journey up the alteration of certain passages. The sagacious Blue River, a rapid stream, with high and Nemours, too, it is said, was angrily opposed to well-wooded banks; visited the ruins of Soba, his sailor-brother: and no wonder if he were. which was the flourishing capital of a Christian The Standard contradicts this tale, "on author. kingdom in the tenth century,—now nothing ity.” At all events, the affair is settled : and but heaps of burnt bricks indicate its site, and no war is likely to follow because de Joinville probably that of a more ancient city, as a has shown in type how he would display his statue of Osiris and a Sphinx (now in Cairo) Prowess. have been found among them, also a little The Journal des Débats has a formidable


But it seems we are menaced in other quarters. bronze statue of Venus, of Grecian workman- of renewed understanding between Russia and ship. On the 27ıh the southern division of the our enemies in the East—a conspiracy extending expedition was at Sennaar, and from thence, from St. Petersburg to Cabul, from Nicholas to about two days further south, to near Seyro, Akhbar Khan; and once more, in the fancy of from whence they returned to Kartoum, froni the Parisian journalist, our Indian empire toiters which place my correspondent dates his letter to its fall! Has some hallucination come over March 22, the thermometer at 105° in the mid- men like these astute French writers ? Imposdle of the day.

sible. But a little anti-British farrago may servo Of other news, they inform me of the revolt as a set-off to the recent lecture administered to of 800 black soldiers, which has since been al- the Prince de Joinville, and may reconcile the layed, and of the appearance of an epidemic ultra-French spirits who took fire at the Débats, resembling the plague, neither of which, thank which was pronounced to be more English than God, affected them.-- I remain, my dear sir, is chosen on which a most terrible attack can be

our Times or Chronicle; and accordingly, a topic yours very truly,

made upon British interests—where it can do J. BONOMI.

no harm—where it can have no present results.Spectator.

[blocks in formation]

SHE MARTYRS OF SCIENCE, prototype of an age in a state of transition
From the Edinburgh Review.

from ignorance and barbarism, to know

ledge and refinement-devoting himself The Martyrs of Science; or, the Lives of with equal zeal to the pursuits of astronoGalileo, Tycho Brahé, and Kepler. By my and astrology, chemistry and alchemy, Sir David Brewster, K. H. D. C. L. and in whose character religion and super12mo. London: 1841.

stition, enlarged views and abject credulity, If the distinguished author of this unpre- were strangely blended. Next we have tending little volume had undertaken to Kepler, also an astrologer, but while pracwrite the history of the origin of Physical tising the art, railing at its vanity and worthAstronomy, he could not have thrown his lessness ;-indulging in the wildest reveries narrative into a more convenient or inter- respecting the laws of the planetary moesting form than by writing the lives of tions, but rigidily subjecting all his fancies Galileo, Tycho Brahé, and Kepler. These to the test of calculation ; refuting his own three names occupy by far the most con- | hypotheses, when he found them inconsisspicuous place in the annals of Astronomy, tent with observation, with as much pabetween those of Copernicus and Newton. tience and complacency as others employ in By explaining the phenomena of the celes- establishing the most important theories; tial motions, on the hypothesis of the imino- speculating on the nature of attraction so bility of the sun and the twofold motion of as almost to anticipate Newton, yet stating at the earth, Copernicus made the first step the same time his belief, that the solid globe towards the true theory of the universe; of the earth is an enormous animal, and that but he did not discard the eccentrics and the tides are produced by the spouting out of epicycles of the ancient faith; and the water through its gills ! Lastly, we have the universally received dogma of antiquity, accomplished and courtly Galileo; a conuniform motion in circular orbits—remain- troversialist, a rhetorician, a inan of the ed undisturbed. In order to proceed a step world; treating with sarcasm and ridicule beyond the point at which Copernicus had the physical dogmas countenanced by the arrived, observations of greater precision, Church, •yet living on terms of intimate and more distinct ideas respecting the laws friendship with its dignitaries; establishing of motion, were necessary. Tycho Brahé the true system of the world with an overfurnished the observations. Kepler, with whelming force of argument, and ranting infinite labor and sagacity, traced out their his doctrines in submission to ecclesiasticonsequences, and proved from them that cal authority. Characters thus marked the planetary orbits are not circles, but ellip- would afford, under any circumstances, inses; and that the motions are not uniform, teresting subjects for biographical sketches; though regulated by a law remarkable for but in the present case, the interest is its simplicity and beauty. Galileo directed greatly increased by the accidents of life the telescope to the heavens; fortified the and position. The persecution of Galileo Copernican doctrine with new proofs; and, by the Catholic Church for maintaining by the discovery of the laws of motion, pre- doctrines which are now regarded as the pared the way for the dynamical theories most certain truths of science; the injuries, of Newton. In effecting this advance from real or imaginary, which compelled Tycho formal to physical astronomy, no other in- to abandon his Observatory, and exile himdividual contributed in any remarkable de- self from his country; the privations and gree; hence the history of their labors miseries of Kepler, whose fate it was to be includes that of the science itself, during one day engaged in working out the laws one of the most interesting periods of its of the universe, and the next in calculating progress.

nativities to procure bread for his children; But if the three individuals just named - the incidents, in short, which entitle them are pre-eminently distinguished for their ser- to be regarded as martyrs of science-have vices to Astronomy, they are not less remark- procured for them the sympathies of the able for their intellectual characters, and the world, and given them a notoriety altogethincidents of their personal histories. They er independent of their scientific discorlived in an age of unusual intellectual activi-eries. ty, when Europe was rousing itself from the It is to the personal, rather than the scitorpor of centuries, and gradually acquiring entific history of these three individuals, the characteristics of our own times. First that Sir David Brewster has chiefly directin chronological order comes Tycho—the ed the attention of his readers in the pres

« VorigeDoorgaan »